Skip to main content

anomalous monism

This thesis by Donald Davidson states that mental events are .... surprise!.... anomalous. They are such b/c they can't be accounted for in terms of the laws of nature that apply to non-living things. They are something more than non-mental events, even though they are purely physical.

If we take this as a description of perception (and set aside questions about the human soul, with its knowledge of universal truths), then Davidson seems to be onto something. And the "monism" here might be taken as "non-dualism," i.e., as not precluding an Aristotelian hylomorphism.

Comments

Unknown said…
What does the last word mean?
5:20 PM
Unknown said…
Also, Walker Percy in his philosophical essays says the same thing about language.
5:25 PM
Leo White said…
Hi Tim,
Good to know that at lest one other human being finds my meanderings worth looking into. Now to your question: hylomorphism is two Greek words patched together. 'Hyle' means matter or stuff, as in the stuff out of which something is made. 'Morphe' means form as in shape. A common Thomistic expression (and Thomists are pretty much Aristotelians) is that soul is the form of the body. In other words, body and soul aren't two interactive entities. Rather, they are two principals of one entity. One "informs" the other. An analogy: just as a visible object always has one form or another, so too matter never exists apart from form. This analogy breaks down a bit because the shape of a thing seems to be less real than that which has the shape, whereas the soul is not less real than the body. I am interested not so much in the matter/form relation as it pertains to the body/soul as I am in the matter/form relation as it pertains to sensation, perception. These cognitive operations says Aquinas, have material and formal aspects. By cognitive operations I don't mean anything spiritual, immaterial, immortal or whatever. What I'm talking about pertains to awareness found in dogs and cats as well as humans. And I don't think dogs or cats have immortal souls.
9:03 AM
Leo White said…
Walker Percy speaks of hylomorphism?
9:03 AM
Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

response to friend who suggested that the self is a democracy of neural parts

This is a nice way to try to avoid being cornered re the irreality of the self if you're a reductionist, for you can assert that a pattern obtains at the microscopic level that is not all that unlike the pattern found at the societal level.  No need for the one self that does it all: instead, you have many sub-selfs that compete for dominance or take turns guiding the whole. The problem with this is, however, that the voters/officials are all zombies.  None of them thinks about the whole as such.  And perhaps none of them thinks even about themselves (unless one is a panzoist).  None of them makes a comparison of alternatives. The more this proposed democracy seems like a zombocracy, the more consciousness will be seem to be epiphenomenal. Furthermore, if the oneness of the self is less real than the multiplicity of explanatory neural parts, then why can't each of these neural parts be conceived of as democracy as well?  And why not parts of these parts, et...
6 comments
Read more

what is an organism?

How about defining it as an instance of functional complexity? And treating the list of properties as following necessarily from this definition? Okay, this is very diamond-in-the-rough (or perhaps zirconium...) but here goes my thoughts on the matter: (Complexity) Many diverse parts (functional) acting for the sake of the whole I think I need to add something like "not as the instrument of another" or something like that. Given that they act together as one whole and given entropy, etc., the organism will need to posses more order than its surroundings (homeostasis). It will therefore need to take in energy (nutrition), which it will use to sustain its readiness to interact with its environment so as to preserve its own being (homeostasis again?), but which will eventually break down (death), so that in order for that life form to continue it will need to duplicate itself (reproduction), which, upon occurring, will involve both development (growth) to maturity and...
13 comments
Read more